We are reader supported, we earn a small commission when you buy something using our retail links.

Training Collar for Large Stubborn Dogs: A Comprehensive Guide

At A Glance

Training collars help instill discipline and encourage positive behavior in dogs. With ethical training practices, safety considerations, professional guidance, and the best dog training collar for stubborn dogs, you can ensure successful training endeavors.

Pairing training collars with the following techniques is key to a well-behaved dog:

  • Positive reinforcement instead of shouting and physical force
  • Timing and consistency in terms of training schedules and rewards

Last Updated on: Oct 25, 2023

custom oil-painted dog portraits by Poshtraits

Instilling discipline in a large, stubborn dog can be incredibly challenging. One valuable tool that can aid in this process is a training collar specifically designed for such breeds.

Training collars help teach obedience and correct undesirable behaviors in dogs. They provide remote communication to deliver corrections or signals (vibrations or sounds) to encourage desired behaviors. They are safe and humane methods to deliver positive reinforcement during training sessions.

In this comprehensive guide, we delve into the best training collar for stubborn dogs, exploring their types, features, benefits, and how to use them effectively.

Types of Training Collars

Large dog breeds naturally exhibit strong-willed personalities. They have boundless energy and a deep desire to assert their independence. Recognizing these inherent traits is fundamental to laying the foundation for successful training endeavors.

The following collars have various features and benefits that aid in training:

Static or Shock Collars

Electric collars deliver a mild electric shock to the dog when triggered. They have varying levels of intensity and are adaptable to different breeds and behaviors. However, they should be used with caution and are generally best suited for experienced trainers who understand when and how to apply them.

Vibration Collars

best training collar for stubborn dogs - vibration collars

Vibration collars utilize gentle vibrations as a form of correction, which are less startling compared to electric shocks. They are best for sensitive or anxious dogs and can reinforce commands without causing discomfort.

Ultrasonic Collars

Ultrasonic collars emit high-frequency sound waves that are unpleasant to dogs but mostly inaudible to humans. When your dog engages in unwanted behavior, the collar emits a sound that interrupts their actions. This can deter barking and other undesirable behaviors.

Citronella Collars

These collars release a burst of citronella spray near your dog’s nose when they misbehave. Dogs find the scent unpleasant, which can deter them from repeating unwanted behavior.

Choosing the Right Training Collar

Finding the right training collar for your dog directly impacts the effectiveness and comfort of your training sessions. You must consider the following:

  • Size – collar size and intensity settings should be appropriate for the dog’s physique.
  • Temperament – some collars may be better suited for sensitive dogs, while others may work well for more assertive breeds.
  • Training goals – are you exploring obedience training, or do you want to address a specific behavior issue?

Making a thoughtful selection ensures a harmonious and productive training experience.

And when you purchase a collar, you must follow manufacturer instructions, use appropriate intensity levels, and prioritize your dog’s well-being.

Training Techniques with Collars

Effectively using a training collar requires a deep understanding of dog behavior and how to change it.

Positive Reinforcement

best dog training collar for stubborn dogs - positive reinforcement

Positive reinforcement involves rewarding desired behaviors with treats, praise, or other positive stimuli, reinforcing the connection between obedience and positive outcomes.

When utilizing training collars, combining corrections with rewards is crucial to create a clear association between the collar’s physical cues and good behavior. This method builds trust and motivation in your dog, making it more receptive to training. You will also maintain a positive and loving bond.

Timing and Consistency

Correcting undesirable behavior must occur at the precise moment the action takes place, ensuring that your dog connects the correction with its behavior.

Consistency in corrections and rewards helps your dog understand what is expected. It reduces confusion and accelerates the learning process.

Comfort and Safety

Each dog is unique, and the efficacy of one collar may not suit another. Intensity should be adjusted to the minimum level needed to elicit a response. Prioritize your dog’s well-being by carefully monitoring its reactions and comfort during training sessions.

When you strike the right balance and ensure your dog’s physical and emotional comfort, you can effectively correct behavior.

Common Training Challenges

Even with the right collar and techniques, challenges may arise during the training process.

Excessive Barking

When used in conjunction with positive reinforcement, training collars can help curb excessive barking, a common issue for large dogs. By interrupting barking patterns and rewarding quiet moments, you can teach your dog when it can make noise and when to remain calm.

Leash Pulling

Dogs that pull on their leashes can make walks frustrating. Training collars with no-pull harnesses or adjustable tension can teach your dog to walk politely by your side.


While training collars can help address aggression in large dogs, it’s best to consult a professional trainer or behaviorist for guidance. They can provide specialized techniques and ensure safety for you and your dog during training.

Safety and Ethical Considerations of Training Collars for Dogs

dog running

When using training collars for large, stubborn dogs, it is paramount to safety ethics. These are critical elements that should guide your training approach.


Your dog’s well-being should always be the top priority. Do not use excessive force or collar intensity levels that could cause physical or emotional harm. Regularly inspect the collar for wear and ensure it fits comfortably on your pet to avoid skin irritation or discomfort.

Ethical Training Practices

Maintaining ethical standards in training is crucial. Utilize positive reinforcement techniques to reward good behavior rather than relying on harsh corrective measures. Do not use training collars as punishment; instead, employ them as tools for communication and teaching.

Professional Guidance

If you are uncertain about using a training collar or if your dog exhibits severe behavioral issues, seek the assistance of a professional trainer or behaviorist. They will provide valuable insights for effective and ethical training. They can offer tailored solutions and guidance to overcome training challenges.

Training collars can be powerful tools for shaping the behavior of large, stubborn dogs. When used correctly and ethically, they offer a humane and effective way to communicate with your pet. Remember that patience, consistency, and positive reinforcement are key to achieving success in training.

With the knowledge gained from this guide, you can embark on a journey to create a strong bond and obedient relationship with your beloved canine companion.


General training collar for stubborn dogs

Previous Article

Havapoo Breeders in Michigan


I am a full-time mum of two kids and a beautiful golden retriever. Writing is my passion: from food journalism to pets, parenting tips, etc. I can write on just about everything under the sun. I have been writing for the past 7 years and during that time, I have been a regular contributor to several blogs and pet magazines. I have also written feature articles, POV pieces, and dabbled in a few different formats of writing over the years.